Top 5 Best Scotty Cameron Putters Of All Time (Reviewed)

Love golf but dread putting? Struggling to find a club that perfectly fits your style of game? 

Never fear! This helpful guide has everything you need to know about the top 5 best Scotty Cameron putters of all time.

Quick Summary: Our Top Picks For Scotty Cameron Putters On The Market In 2022

IMAGE	PRODUCT
Best Scotty Cameron Putter	Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter Great feel coming off the clubface Classic design 303 Stainless steel clubhead	VIEW LATEST PRICE →
Best Scotty Cameron Blade	Scotty Cameron Special Select Del Mar Putter 303 Stainless material Soft Tri-Sole Design Tour-inspired shape	VIEW LATEST PRICE →
Best Traditional Mallet Putter	Scotty Cameron Fastback Putter Solid feel Soft face inlay Made with aircraft aluminum	VIEW LATEST PRICE →
Best for Forgiveness	Scotty Cameron Phantom X 8.5 Putter Better toe flow increased hang Easy alignment Unique looking clubhead design	VIEW LATEST PRICE →
Best for Arc Putting Stroke	Scotty Cameron Special Select Squareback 2 Putter No face inlay Heel and toe balanced Easier to align than a traditional blade	VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Best Scotty Cameron Putter: Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2

At the top of our list is the Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2. The Newport 2 makes it to the top because of the classic look and feel of the club.

This is one of the best blade putters design that has been around for many years, but Scotty puts out a new one every few years. 

This putter is made with a solid 303 stainless steel and gives it very consistent performance, feel, and sound. It does not matter what your handicap is; this is a putter that will likely improve your feel and ability to make putts. 

The Scotty Cameron Newport 2 Standards also has a new Soft Tri-Sole Design. This is to help golfers have a great topline view and stability at impact as well.

The new raw stainless finish is glare resistant so that golfers are not squinting when they try and roll their putts. 

The Newport 2 is a tour-proven design that will allow you to square up the face and roll more putts into the hole. If you are a golfer that likes simplicity and function, the Newport 2 is the way to go.

Key Features and Technology

• Improved sound and feel from previous models
• New Soft Tri Sole Design 
• Easy to square up the putter face

What Customers Say about Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2

The Special Select Newport 2 also allows you to customize it to suit your specific style and preferences. With options to change the grip, shaft length, and head finish, you really can make this amazing club do anything.

Customers love this putter too, applauding the Special Select 2’s design and accuracy. The features that gained special attention include its perfect size, shape, and weight, as well as its straight putt.

Best Scotty Cameron Blade: Scotty Cameron Special Select Del Mar Putter

The Scotty Cameron Select Del Mar is part of the same Special Select group of putters.

This is a mallet-style design, and it is a perfect solution for the mid handicapper that needs some extra forgiveness in a putter design but still wants that Scotty Cameron feel. 

With the Del Mar, you will get the Performance Balanced Weighting that will direct more weight to the heel and the toe of the putter.

This helped Scotty Cameron to increase the size of the sweet spot. In general, mallet putters tend to be a little more forgiving and a better fit for the straight back, straight through shots. 

The putter heads on the Special Select series are tour inspired, giving golfers a sleeker look. The topline is flatter, and there is no question that these Del Mar Scotty Cameron putters have players look to them.

Key Features and Technologies

• Performance balanced weighting 
• More forgiving 
• Players type look

What Customers Say about Scotty Cameron Special Select Del Mar Putter

The Del Mar has multiple aesthetic upgrades too. New Super Select graphics, shaft band, and headcover are all present – not to mention the cherry red translucent and asphalt paint fill! 

Customers simply can’t get enough of the Special Select Del Mar Putter’s precision and milled face design. Its milled face feels like no other, and has the added perk of actually sitting square to the target line when soled!

Best Traditional Mallet Putter: Scotty Cameron Fastback Putter

The Scotty Cameron Fastback is not the newest release from Scotty, but it is certainly a choice worth considering.

The Fastback is made with a 6061 aircraft-grade aluminum and a face inlay. The face inlay is designed to give a higher MOI and a more balanced feel. 

Just like the other Scotty Camerons on the market, the Fastback is designed to sit perfectly square at address. This feature will help golfers with alignment and consistency.

The stainless steel bodies on the Scotty Cameron Fastback help to give it a very balanced and stable feel at impact. 

Not all golfers like a putter with a face inlay, but this Fastback has a solid feel at impact with little to no vibration. The shape of the Fastback is a bit like a blade mixed with a mallet.

If you are one of those players that can’t decide which is the best putter design for you, this could be a great choice.

Key Features and Technologies

• Sits perfectly square at address
• Face inlay with no vibration 
• Stainless steel body for longevity

What Customers Say about Scotty Cameron Fastback Putter

The Flashback Putter also features a new textured Pistolero Plus grip. This grip has a larger profile in the top-hand location near the base and is also relatively heavier than the Pistolini Plus grip.

Customers boast about the Flashback Putter’s accuracy and consistency and are particularly impressed by its amazing feel and sound. Many praise how it hits the ball straight, as well as helping you hit putts with consistent speed no matter your swing length.

Scotty Cameron Phantom X 8.5 Putter

Best for Forgiveness

Most of the time, golfers don’t think of the Scotty Cameron putters as being forgiving. However, the truth is, if you find the right match for your game, they can be very forgiving.

Generally speaking, the larger mallet style design putters have more forgiveness because their club head is so much larger, and the sweet spot is bigger. 

The Phantom X 8.5 putter is a very unique looking option. If you have ever played with the Scotty Cameron Futura, you can think of this as the update and replacement.

The 8.5 has a bit of a bend in the shaft to help players with alignment and a true roll at impact. 

If you have a slight arc in your putting stroke, the Phantom is the club to consider.

Generally speaking, the larger mallet putters are best for the straight back straight through putting strokes, but the Phantom X putter will work for the arc as well.

Key Features and Technologies

• Larger mallet style
• Large sweet spot 
• More forgiving than other Scotty Cameron putters
• Helps with straight back/straight through putting stroke

What Customers Say about Scotty Cameron Phantom X 8.5 Putter

For golfers with a heavier swing, the Phantom X 8.5 Putter also features adjustable weight ports in the sole near the face of the club. 10, 15, or 20-gram weights can all be added to the head depending on personal preference.

But don’t take it from me, plenty of customers also have a lot to say about the Phantom X 8.5 Putter’s balance and feel. Honorable mentions include how its weight and balance help with ball confidence and the amazing feel, making it one of the most popular choices for putters.

Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Squareback 2 Putter

Best for Arc Putting Stroke

The way we like to describe the Squareback 2 putter is the big brother of a blade style putter.

When you look at the classic blades that Scotty Cameron has put out, you will see that this Squareback comes out quite a bit further in the back.

If you love a blade style putter, but you want something that is a bit easier to align, the Squareback is a great choice. 

This is another option in the Special Select series so that you will benefit from the Soft Tri-Sole design and the great looking top line.

This putter has a high performing face that is precision milled from one piece of 303 stainless. 

We love this putter for the lower handicapper that wants something a bit different than a blade but is not ready to go to a mallet style putter design.

Key Features and Technologies

• Similar to blade functionality 
• Made from 303 Stainless steel 
• High performing face for great consistency

What Customers Say about Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Squareback 2 Putter

This putter is also relatively heavier than others. This is because of the 6601 aluminum sole. Not to worry though, the Special Select Squareback 2 has adjustable features to help decrease the weight. 

Not yet convinced? Customers everywhere talk about the Special Select Squareback 2 Putter’s control and stability, and how it offers speed control and feel that’s unmatched among many putters.

Scotty Cameron Putters Buying Guide

Scotty Cameron putters are a unique purchase. Once you buy one, you will likely never buy another kind of putter again.

There are a few things that are important to know before you purchase your first Cameron putter. 

Why Are Scotty Cameron Putters The Best? 

The main thing that makes the Scotty Cameron putters stand out is the precision and the technology.

These putters have had thousands of hours of research and design poured into them, and they have been tested and proven on the PGA Tour. 

Most amateur golfers believe that if a tour player is using a club, it will help their game. Although this is not always the case, switching to the Scotty is very likely going to be a positive addition to your game.

Very few people are disappointed by the manufacturing, design, or feel of a Scotty Cameron. 

How Do I Choose A Scotty Cameron Putter? 

When it comes to finding the best putters for your game, you need to start with your stroke type. If you have a straight back and straight through putting stroke, then you will probably want a mallet type design. For the arc putting stroke, the blade style putter is a better fit. 

Once you have the type of putter narrowed down, you should consider if you want a face inlay or a precision milled face. Most of the time, the face inlays are going to offer a slightly softer feel. This will come down to more of a personal preference than a performance type of decision. 

When you have your putter head style, the face inlay, and your stroke figured out, there will probably only be a few current models to choose from.

Scotty Cameron always keeps certain classic putters available, but they will not put new putters out every few months. Sometimes buying a used Scotty Cameron makes sense if there is no availability in the most recent designs. 

Are Scotty Cameron Putters Worth It? 

The one downside to the Scotty Cameron Putter is the price. There is one question that these putters are priced at the top of the market.

They do not offer a value putter in any style. When you want a Scotty, you must commit to spending several hundred dollars. 

For golfers that struggle with spending a lot of money on a putter, they need to consider how many times during a round of golf the putter is used.

You will use your putter more than any other club in your bag, and therefore spending some extra money on a quality design may make a lot of sense. 

When you compare the price of a Scotty to a new driver from TaylorMade or Callaway, the price will look like a bargain.

Most players will use their driver only 12 or so times in a round of golf. Putters come out of the bag twenty five or more times in the course of a round of golf. 

Types of Putters 

There are two basic types of putters that golfers need to choose from. These are the blade and the mallet putter. Both the blade and the mallet have impressive technology and features; the key is to find a putter that works for your individual needs. Here are a few of the most important things to know about the blade vs. mallet putter. 

Mallet

A mallet putter is a more forgiving option that works best for golfers with a straight back and straight through style putting stroke. With the mallet style, putter golfers can square the clubface up quite easily and get some better distance control.

Mallet putters are designed to work for a wide range of handicaps, and the new modern mallets are offering more technology than we have seen from a mallet putter in the past. With the larger club head size players get a lot more flexibility in what they can do with the club. 

Blade 

A blade style putter is designed to work best for those with an arc style putting stroke. Blade style putters are typically considered to be a good option for faster greens and better players. However, many beginner golf sets are sold with a blade putter. Essentially you must find the putter that looks the best and performs most consistently for your needs. 

What to look for when buying a putter?

Choosing a putter can be a bit tricky. There are some really great options on the market, even outside of the Scotty Cameron golf brand. If you think that you may want to purchase a new golf putter, here are the things that you should keep in mind. 

Grip

A putter grip is going to be different from the other grips in your golf bag. With a putting grip, you typically have a flatter front panel for your hands to rest on. In addition, many grips are going to be a thicker design so that players can eliminate some of their hand and wrist motion in the putting stroke. 

Shaft

The golf shaft is not as important in a putter as in some other clubs. However, in recent years, studies have been done to show that having a steel or a graphite/steel mix shaft can lead to some more consistency. 

Forgiveness

The more forgiving a putter is, the easier it is for a golfer to repeat their putting stroke. The most forgiving putters are typically mallet type putters with a larger sweet spot than standard. In addition, many forgiving putters have a long alignment line to help golfers line their shots up to the hole. 

Look/Feel

The look and feel of a putter need to match the needs of a player. Most of the time the Scotty Cameron putters have some of the best feel on the market, so this should not be a major concern for the golfers that play Scotty Cameron clubs. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

Here are a few of the most commonly asked questions we get about the best Scotty Cameron putters of all time. As Scotty Cameron continues to put out new models, this list will only continue to expand.

Conclusion

If you have been indecisive about whether or not to get one of the new Cameron putters, hopefully, our guide has helped narrow things down for you.

The Scotty Cameron Newport putter stands at the top of our list because of the balanced feel, the weighting, and the classic look.

This is a club that has many PGA Tour victories to its name, and it is something that can take your game to the next level.

The great thing about all of these putters in our review is they will earn a spot in your bag for many years to come; the Scotty Cameron putters do not expire!